Why This By Rod Stewart Was One Of His Most Overlooked Later-Era Tracks

March 21, 2025

Rod Stewart is a name that often brings to mind classic hits like “Maggie May” and “Do Ya Think I’m Sexy?” But there’s a hidden gem in his later work that many fans overlook: “Why This.” Released in 1998 on the album “When We Were the New Boys,” this song tells a poignant story of love and longing, capturing emotions that resonate deeply despite its lesser-known status.

As I listen to “Why This,” I can’t help but feel the weight of Rod’s experiences woven into the lyrics. By the time this song came out, Rod had weathered personal storms that would have broken a lesser artist. He had gone through a series of relationships, failures, and triumphs. Each heartbreak and joy shaped him into the passionate musician he is. “Why This” reflects that journey; it’s as if he’s asking himself why love can be so complicated and painful while also being the greatest source of happiness. His voice, gravelly yet tender, carries the weight of those questions, inviting listeners to share in his vulnerability.

Despite its emotional depth, “Why This” didn’t receive the recognition it deserved. At a time when pop music was dominated by flashy trends and youthful voices, Rod’s soulful style felt almost out of place. The song’s soulful melody and heartfelt lyrics seemed to get lost in a sea of more commercial tunes. Yet, those who took the time to listen were rewarded with a rich narrative that spoke to the heart. The song became a reminder that even in a changing music landscape, the core of Rod’s artistry remained strong.

Rod’s resilience shines through in his ability to continue creating impactful music even when the world seemed to overlook him. Rather than succumb to frustration, he poured his energy into crafting songs that reflected his life experiences. “Why This” became a testament to his ongoing passion for music—a passion that refused to diminish, no matter the obstacles. Through ups and downs, he showed that true artistry is not just about hits and radio play; it’s about pouring your soul into every note and lyric.

Over the years, many fans have revisited Rod’s discography, and “Why This” has started to find its place in the hearts of listeners. It’s as if people are beginning to realize that this song encapsulates a universal truth about love: it’s messy, beautiful, and often leaves us questioning our choices. Rod Stewart, through “Why This,” offers a glimpse into his own heart while also inviting us to reflect on our own experiences with love and loss.

In the end, “Why This” stands as a quiet reminder that not all treasures shine brightly at first glance. Sometimes, the most profound pieces are those that require patience to appreciate. Rod Stewart may have had his share of chart-topping hits, but it’s tracks like “Why This” that truly reveal the depth of his artistry and the resilience of his spirit. This song teaches us that even in times of struggle, we can find beauty in vulnerability and strength in our shared experiences.