The Session Where Stealers Wheel Re-Recorded “Star” Three Times — And Kept The First Take

April 2, 2025

The dimly lit studio was filled with the sound of buzzing cables and scattered instruments as the members of Stealers Wheel prepared to record their song “Star.” It was a sunny afternoon in 1973, but inside, the atmosphere was focused and intense. The band, known for their hit “Stuck in the Middle with You,” gathered around their microphones, each musician feeling a mix of excitement and nervousness. They had waited months to get into the studio again, and this song was special. It had a melody that sparked joy and lyrics that spoke of dreams and hope.

As they started to play, the sound of guitars and drums melded together, creating an almost magical atmosphere. The band performed with passion, pouring their hearts into each note. After finishing the first take, they exchanged glances filled with hope. The producer, however, believed they could do even better. So, they decided to try again, eager to capture the essence of the song even more perfectly. They recorded the second take, this one filled with an even more vibrant energy. Yet, as they listened to it back, they felt something was missing. Frustration began to creep in, but their resolve remained strong. “Let’s do it one more time!” they shouted, pushing their creative limits.

The third take came and went, but even as they played, they could feel the weight of expectation hanging in the air. When it ended, silence filled the studio as they sat there, wondering if this final attempt would be the one. After reviewing all three recordings, the band and the producer came to an unexpected conclusion: the very first take, the one filled with raw emotion and imperfections, was the one they loved the most. It was as if that first attempt had captured the essence of what they wanted to convey, vibrant and real, just like the spirit of the song.

This decision was a turning point for Stealers Wheel. It reminded them that sometimes, the initial spark of creativity holds more magic than the polished version we strive to create. The song “Star” went on to capture the hearts of many, but the experience of that day was invaluable for the band. It taught them resilience—the importance of trusting their instincts and embracing imperfection. They learned that music is not always about being perfect, but about expressing genuine feelings and connecting with others.

As time passed, Stealers Wheel would face their fair share of challenges, including lineup changes and the pressures of the music industry. However, they would often reflect on that day in the studio, remembering the joy and freedom they felt in creating “Star.” The lesson they learned—about embracing spontaneity and being true to themselves—became a guiding principle in their music. They realized that each song, like life, may not always turn out the way you expect, but with passion and authenticity, it can still shine brightly. In the end, it wasn’t just a song; it was a testament to their journey and an inspiration to keep reaching for the stars.