The Time Anthrax Performed Live With No Setlist, Taking Requests On The Spot

March 20, 2025

It was a warm summer evening in 2017, and a buzz filled the air at the small venue in downtown Chicago. The anticipation was palpable as fans filed into the room, eager to see Anthrax, one of the legendary bands of thrash metal. But this concert was different. The band had decided to perform without a setlist, a daring choice that set the stage for something unpredictable and exciting. As the lights dimmed and the deafening cheers erupted, the band members glanced at each other, grinning with a mix of nerves and exhilaration.

As the first chord rang out, the lead singer, Joey Belladonna, encouraged the crowd to shout out their song requests. He was a charismatic performer, with a voice that could soar over the heavy guitars like a bird in flight. The audience erupted, calling out titles from the band’s extensive discography. “How about ‘Caught in a Mosh’?” someone yelled. Without hesitation, the band launched into the song, and the crowd went wild. Bodies surged toward the stage, fists pumping and heads banging. In that moment, it felt like everyone in the room was connected, creating a shared wave of energy that coursed through each person.

As the night wore on, the spontaneous song requests kept coming. Fans shouted for deep cuts and fan favorites alike, while Anthrax effortlessly transitioned from one song to the next, showcasing their vast musical catalog. The unpredictability made every moment thrilling; no one knew what song would come next. For the band, it was a refreshing challenge that reignited their passion for performing. They had played countless setlists before, but this night was all about the connection with their fans. It was raw, real, and stripped down to the essence of what music was all about.

But the night took a poignant turn when someone in the crowd called for “I Am the Law.” It was a reminder of the band’s resilience, a song that spoke to standing strong in the face of adversity. Joey dedicated the song to those who had faced struggles in life but stood tall, just like the band had throughout their career. This wasn’t just a performance anymore; it became an anthem of hope and perseverance. The crowd sang every word back, and for those minutes, it felt as if they could overcome anything.

After the show, fans left with smiles on their faces, and the band members felt a sense of renewal. Taking requests on the spot had brought them closer to their audience, reminding them why they loved making music in the first place. This experience led to a new chapter in their career, inspiring Anthrax to embrace more improvisational performances in the future. They realized that sometimes, the best moments in life come from taking risks and being open to change.

That night in Chicago became a defining moment for Anthrax and its fans, proving that music has the power to unite people and spark joy. It wasn’t just about the songs; it was about the moments they created together, filled with laughter, energy, and a sense of community. For Joey and his bandmates, this experience reignited their passion for music and served as a reminder that the heart of a true artist lies in their connection with their audience, no setlist required.