How Elton John Nearly Gave “Candle In The Wind” To Another Singer

April 2, 2025

In the early 1970s, Elton John was riding high on the success of his music career. With his flamboyant style and powerful voice, he captivated audiences around the world. One of his most famous songs, “Candle in the Wind,” was written in 1973 as a tribute to Marilyn Monroe. While the song would eventually become a defining moment for Elton, there was a time when he almost handed it over to another artist, a decision that could have changed everything.

The story began when Elton and his longtime collaborator, Bernie Taupin, were crafting the lyrics for “Candle in the Wind.” They poured their hearts into the song, reflecting on the life of a troubled star who struggled in the spotlight. However, when Elton finished recording the track, he thought it might be better suited for another singer: the legendary singer-songwriter, Bette Midler. Known for her powerful voice and emotional performances, Bette seemed like a perfect fit to add her unique touch to the song. Elton even considered giving her the rights to perform it, believing that she would bring the song to life in a way that he hadn’t imagined.

But just before he made the decision, something stopped him. Elton felt a deep connection to the song and realized that it was part of his own journey. Bette, with all her talent, couldn’t possibly tell the story the way he could. With a sudden surge of inspiration, he decided to keep “Candle in the Wind” for himself, believing in his passion and the emotions behind the music. It was a defining moment for the artist, reminding him that sometimes, the songs closest to your heart are the ones that truly belong to you.

When “Candle in the Wind” was finally released, it became an instant classic, especially when Elton performed it at Princess Diana’s funeral in 1997, rewriting the lyrics to honor her memory. The heartfelt rendition was a touching tribute that resonated with millions, further cementing Elton’s legacy in music history. He had chosen to hold onto a piece of himself, and in doing so, he transformed not just his career, but the lives of so many who heard the song.

Reflecting on that period, Elton realized how close he came to letting someone else tell his story. He often shares this lesson with aspiring musicians: sometimes your greatest creations come from the depths of your own experiences. Instead of handing them over to others, have the courage to stand by your work and let it shine through your unique voice. This resilience not only shaped his career but inspired countless artists who looked up to him.

In the end, “Candle in the Wind” became more than just a song; it was a testament to the power of sticking to your convictions and the importance of believing in yourself. Elton John’s journey reminds us all that even in moments of uncertainty, we can find strength in our passion and turn our stories into songs that can touch the hearts of many.