The Argument Over Which Song Would Open Takin’ It To The Streets

April 1, 2025

The sun was setting on a crisp autumn day in 1976, casting a golden hue over the streets of Los Angeles. Inside the small rehearsal studio, the air was thick with anticipation and tension. The members of The Doobie Brothers were gathered, their voices raised in an intense argument. The question at hand was a big one: which song would open their new album, “Takin’ It to the Streets”? Each member had their own favorite, and as the minutes ticked away, so did their patience.

At the center of the discussion was Michael McDonald, the band’s new addition who had a voice that could stir the soul. With his smooth, heartfelt sound, he had quickly become a fan favorite. Michael believed that “Take Me in Your Arms (Rock Me a Little While)” would set the perfect tone for the album. It was soulful, passionate, and had the potential to hook listeners right from the start. His enthusiasm was palpable, but not everyone shared his vision.

Tom Johnston, the band’s original frontman, strongly argued for the song “Takin’ It to the Streets”. He felt that this title track, with its powerful message of social change and resilience, encapsulated what the band wanted to convey to the world. “This isn’t just a collection of songs; it’s a statement!” he insisted. Emotions ran high as each member expressed their opinions, and it felt like the very essence of the band was on the line. They had all worked so hard to get to this point, and the choice of the opening track seemed to carry the weight of their dreams.

As the argument reached a boiling point, Michael took a deep breath and spoke from the heart. “Guys, this isn’t just about personal preference. It’s about connecting with people,” he said, his voice steady but passionate. He shared a story about how music had helped him through challenging times in his life, and how he believed both songs had the power to resonate with their audience. That moment of vulnerability shifted the atmosphere in the room. They realized they weren’t just fighting over some notes and lyrics; they were fighting for the same shared purpose: to make music that mattered.

After hours of heated discussion, they finally reached a compromise that would become a pivotal moment in their careers. They would open with “Takin’ It to the Streets” and follow it with “Take Me in Your Arms.” The decision not only strengthened their bond as a band but also set the stage for an album that would define their sound and solidify their place in music history. “Takin’ It to the Streets” would go on to become one of their most iconic songs, highlighting themes of unity and empowerment that resonated deeply with listeners during a time of social upheaval.

The release of the album catapulted The Doobie Brothers to new heights, earning them critical acclaim and a dedicated fanbase. Michael learned that music was not just about individual expression; it was also about collaboration and finding common ground. The argument may have begun with tension, but it ended with a renewed sense of purpose and camaraderie. Through their resilience and shared passion, they not only created a powerful album but also forged a lasting legacy that continues to inspire artists today.