The Fight Over The Saxophone Solo In “Never Tear Us Apart” And Who Wanted It Removed

April 2, 2025

In the heart of a bustling music studio in the 1980s, the air was thick with creativity and tension. The band INXS was in the middle of recording their new album when a fierce debate erupted. At the center of the disagreement was a saxophone solo, a hauntingly beautiful moment that appeared in their hit song “Never Tear Us Apart.” While some members of the band were swept away by its emotional depth, others, including the band’s producer, were convinced that the solo had to go. They believed it took away from the song’s raw energy and drive, making it too slow for radio play. This moment felt like a battle for the soul of the song, and those involved knew the outcome could steer the band’s career in a direction they couldn’t predict.

Kirk Pengilly, the band’s guitarist, was the one who fought hardest to keep the saxophone solo. He had composed the part, pouring his heart and soul into the notes, believing it encapsulated the very essence of the song—a plea for love and connection amidst a chaotic world. Every time he played it, he felt the music wrap around him like a warm embrace. To him, the solo wasn’t just an addition; it was the song’s heartbeat, the part that resonated with listeners’ emotions. But as discussions became more heated, he feared that his beloved solo would be lost forever in the relentless pursuit of commercial success.

As the arguments dragged on, Kirk found himself feeling torn. Should he prioritize the band’s potential for stardom, or should he stand firm for the art he believed in? After hours of negotiation, the band finally decided to have a vote. With his heart racing, Kirk stood before his bandmates, knowing that everything could change in a heartbeat. He spoke passionately about the solo, sharing the feelings behind the music and how it had the power to connect deeply with their audience. His words struck a chord, and the tide began to turn. The band members realized that this moment was not just about a saxophone solo, but about their identity as artists.

In the end, the vote was close, but the solo remained. When “Never Tear Us Apart” was finally released, listeners fell in love with the song. It climbed the charts and became one of INXS’s most iconic tracks. The saxophone solo, once a point of contention, emerged as a defining feature of the piece, sweeping fans off their feet during live performances. Kirk felt a rush of pride every time he played it, knowing that he had stood his ground for what he believed in. The validation was more than just a success; it was an affirmation of the power of music and the importance of staying true to one’s vision.

This experience taught the band invaluable lessons about collaboration and the creative process. They learned that music is not just about numbers and chart positions; it’s about emotion, connection, and the stories behind the notes. Kirk’s passion and determination had not only saved the saxophone solo but also solidified the band’s bond. With every performance of “Never Tear Us Apart,” they shared a piece of their journey, inspiring countless fans to hold onto their dreams and fight for what they believe in. Together, they proved that music could transcend barriers and create a lasting impact, one note at a time.