The Rolling Stone Review That Called Echo “Too Sad” — And Petty Wrote “Good” In The Margins

April 1, 2025

Tom Petty was sitting in the dim light of his studio, surrounded by crumpled papers filled with lyrics and ideas swirling in his mind. It was 1999, and he was just about to release his album “Echo.” This album was special to him, reflecting his personal struggles, heartbreaks, and the deep sense of loss he had been feeling. Every note and word was like carving a piece of his soul into music. He knew it was a sad record, but for him, it was the truth, and he felt that truth needed to be shared.

When the Rolling Stone review came out, it hit him like a cold wave. The critic had called “Echo” “too sad,” as if sadness was a flaw instead of a heartfelt emotion. Petty leaned back in his chair, letting the words soak in. He grabbed a pencil and wrote “Good” in the margins of the review, a single word that encapsulated his response. To him, the sadness was not something to shy away from; it was a testament to the human experience. He believed music should explore the depths of our emotions, not just the highs. In that moment, Tom realized that while the critics might not understand his vision, he had remained true to himself.

As the days went by, Petty reflected on the review and felt a fire ignite within him. Instead of letting the negative feedback pull him down, he used it as fuel for his music. He recognized that sadness was not the end; it was often a beginning, a doorway to understanding, healing, and even resilience. Fans reached out, sharing with him how the songs spoke to their own struggles. “Echo” became a bridge connecting them through shared pain and the hope that followed.

The album went on to receive praise from many listeners who found solace in its honesty. Petty’s willingness to embrace the darker sides of life resonated deeply, turning what some viewed as a flaw into a powerful strength. Over the years, “Echo” became one of his defining works, celebrated for its authenticity. It reminded everyone that even in moments of sadness, there is beauty and strength to be found.

Years later, sitting in a crowded venue, he watched the audience sing along to the songs from “Echo.” Their voices filled the air, harmonizing with his as they celebrated not only the music but the shared experiences that came with it. Tom smiled, knowing that the Rolling Stone review had challenged him but ultimately pushed him to create something real and impactful. He had turned a critique into a catalyst for connection, demonstrating that vulnerability in art could bring people together.

In the end, Tom Petty’s journey with “Echo” taught him that every feeling, even the sad ones, had a place in the world. Music was not just about happy tunes; it was about weaving through life’s complexities, and embracing every emotion along the way. His simple, powerful response to the harsh critique became a mantra for many: sometimes, the truth can be sad, and that’s perfectly okay.