Why “Devil In Her Heart” Was One Of The Beatles’ Most Unusual Cover Choices

March 20, 2025

In the heart of the 1960s, a time when music not only entertained but also spoke to the soul of a generation, The Beatles were carving out a legacy that would echo through the ages. Among their many hits, one cover song stood out as particularly unusual — “Devil in Her Heart.” Originally recorded by The Donays, this song was not one of the band’s biggest hits or a personal favorite of the members. Yet, it was chosen for their album “With The Beatles,” and that choice sent ripples through the music scene. Little did they know, it would become a defining moment for The Beatles and a fascinating tale of unexpected triumph.

The Donays, an all-girl group from Detroit, had a modest career that never quite took off, despite their catchy sound. Their version of “Devil in Her Heart” had a haunting melody and sharp lyrics that captured the essence of heartbreak — themes that resonated with many people at the time. When The Beatles decided to cover this song, it was a bold move. They were known for their upbeat hits and infectious energy, and slipping in a darker, more dramatic tune was a gamble that could easily have gone wrong. George Harrison, the lead guitarist, took the lead vocals, pouring passion into every note, making it his own while respecting its origins.

The decision to transform a lesser-known track into a Beatles classic is a testament to the band’s fearless creativity. They never played by the rules; instead, they took risks, blending their signature sound with the essence of the original. This covered song showcased not just their musical range, but also their ability to breathe new life into something that might have otherwise faded into obscurity. It was a chance to prove that beauty can emerge from unexpected places, and for the band, it was a step toward artistic growth that many fans still treasure today.

As the song was released, it sparked conversations and debates among critics and fans alike. Some were unsure about this unusual choice — why pick a song that was not a chart-topper? But The Beatles stood firm, believing in the power of every song to stir emotion and tell a story. “Devil in Her Heart” resonated deeply with listeners, and the cover breathed new life into The Donays’ version, giving them a renewed sense of purpose. The success of the cover opened doors for many artists who had previously struggled, reminding them that their work could inspire even the biggest names in music.

As time passed, “Devil in Her Heart” became a symbol of resilience. The Beatles not only underscored the importance of creativity and collaboration, but they also showed that every voice matters, no matter how small it may seem. Their choice to cover this song inspired countless musicians who dared to take risks, reminding them that sometimes the most unusual choices can lead to the most beautiful outcomes. For The Beatles, this cover became a chapter in their story, demonstrating their boundless passion for music and their willingness to embrace the unexpected.

In the end, “Devil in Her Heart” wasn’t just a cover; it was a reminder that art transcends fame and recognition. Music has a unique way of connecting people, and The Beatles knew that by choosing a song that spoke about heartbreak and resilience, they were not just honoring a lesser-known artist but also adding depth to their own journey. The impact of that choice still inspires musicians and fans today, proving that creativity knows no bounds and that every song has the power to touch hearts.